Car Accident Insurance Claim: From Crash to Keys

A car accident throws a lot at you at once. There’s the shock of the wreck, then the phone calls, the tow, the paperwork, and the question of when you’ll have your car back. Most people only go through a car accident insurance claim a handful of times in their life, so it’s hard to know what’s normal and what to push on.

Here’s the whole process from start to finish, what to expect at each stage, and where you can make it go smoother.

Step 1: At the Scene

  • Make sure everyone is safe. Call 911 if anyone is hurt or the cars are blocking traffic.
  • Call the police so there’s a report on file. If no one was hurt and the damage is minor, the police may not come out. In that case, take good notes: the time, the location, what happened, and the names and phone numbers of any witnesses.
  • If it was a hit and run, file a police report. Do this even if the damage is minor.
  • Take photos of both cars, the scene, and the other driver’s license plate.
  • Get the other driver’s information: name, phone number, insurance company, and policy number.

Don’t argue about who was at fault, and don’t apologize. The insurance companies will sort out fault. If the other driver is mean or aggressive, call the police.

Step 2: File Your Car Accident Insurance Claim With the Right Carrier

If the other driver was at fault, file your claim with their insurance company, not yours. Their liability coverage pays for your repairs and your rental, and you don’t pay a deductible. Use the other driver’s insurance information you got at the scene to start the claim.

If you were at fault, it isn’t clear who was, or the other driver didn’t have insurance, file with your own insurance company as soon as you can, ideally the same day. Not sure how to reach your carrier’s claims line? Call us. We’ll get you the number and advise you on next steps.

Either way, you’ll get a claim number. Write it down, because you’ll use it in every call from here on. An adjuster will be assigned to your claim and will reach out to you.

Calling the claim in yourself makes it go quicker. The adjuster will want to take a statement from you anyway, so going straight to them saves a step. (Here are our insurance claim tips for making that go smoothly.)

Step 3: Getting the Car Moved

If your car can’t be driven, you get to decide where it’s towed. Have it towed directly to a repair shop, ideally one of your carrier’s preferred shops. That way it’s already where it needs to be, and you avoid storage fees at a tow yard.

Step 4: Choosing the Repair Shop

Almost every carrier we work with has a network of preferred repair shops, and we recommend using them whenever you can:

  • They bill the carrier directly. You pay your deductible and that’s it.
  • The process moves faster. The shop and the carrier already work together, so there’s less back-and-forth on estimates and approvals.
  • They keep claim costs down. Preferred shops work at agreed rates, which saves a lot of money on the claim.

If Your Car Is Too Specialized for the Network

Some cars need more than a standard body shop. Electric vehicles, cars with driver-assist technology (cameras, radar sensors, automatic braking), and specialty makes often need a shop that’s certified by the manufacturer. If no preferred shop can take your car, the carrier may approve whatever qualified shop you find and reimburse the cost.

That’s a fair offer, but it puts the legwork on you. Start with your dealership, since some have their own certified body shop and others send work to one they trust. Before the car moves, ask the shop:

  • Are you certified by the manufacturer for this make?
  • Will you bill my insurance company directly?
  • How soon can you take the car, and when can you start?

Then ask your adjuster to approve the shop, pay for the second tow and any storage fees directly, and pay the shop directly so you’re not fronting the cost.

Step 5: The Estimate and Repairs

Your insurance company will provide an initial estimate, but the final payout for repairs is often more than that first number. Once the shop takes the car apart, it usually finds damage nobody could see at first. That’s normal. The shop sends a supplement to the adjuster for the extra work, and it can add some time to the repair.

If the repairs would cost more than the car is worth, the carrier may declare it a total loss. That’s a different process: instead of repairing the car, the carrier pays you its value.

Step 6: Your Rental Car

If your policy includes rental reimbursement, you can usually get a rental while your car is in the shop, up to your policy’s daily and total limits. If the other driver was at fault, their carrier handles the rental under their liability coverage. Check your limits early so you’re not surprised if the repair runs long.

Step 7: Picking Up Your Car

Pay your deductible to the shop and do a walk-around before you drive off:

  • Check that the repairs look right and the paint matches.
  • Make sure no warning lights are on.
  • For newer cars, confirm that the cameras and sensors were recalibrated.
  • Get a copy of the final repair invoice and any warranty on the work.

When to Call Your Agent

Most claims move along fine between you and your adjuster. Call us if:

  • The adjuster goes quiet and you can’t get a callback
  • Your car is stuck at a shop that can’t repair it
  • You’re being asked to front costs you can’t cover
  • The rental limit is about to run out

That’s when we step in. We’ll help you find the right shop, take the follow-up with your adjuster off your plate, and call you back at a set time with an update, even if the update is “still waiting.”

In the middle of a claim that’s going nowhere? Call GIBB Insurance Services. We serve clients across DFW and The Woodlands.

Call 214-324-3660

About GIBB Insurance Services

GIBB Insurance Services is an independent, woman-owned insurance agency founded by Susana Gibb in 1997, with offices in Dallas and The Woodlands, Texas. Susana Gibb was named one of D Magazine’s Best Insurance Agents in 2024, 2025 and 2026, and GIBB agent Zack Lemons joined her on the 2026 list. We write home, auto, business, flood, and group health insurance across DFW and The Woodlands, plus surety bonds nationwide.

Dallas: 10000 N. Central Expressway, Suite 770, Dallas, TX 75231
The Woodlands: 8708 Technology Forest Place, Suite 175, The Woodlands, TX 77381
Phone: 214-324-3660

Request A Quote